1
2
3
Wealth and Want | |||||||
... because democracy alone is not enough to produce widely shared prosperity. | |||||||
Home | Essential Documents | Themes | All Documents | Authors | Glossary | Links | Contact Us |
Capital and Labor
H.G Brown: Significant Paragraphs from Henry George's Progress & Poverty, Chapter 8: Why a Land-Value Tax is Better than an Equal Tax on All Property (in the unabridged P&P: Book VIII: Application of the Remedy — Chapter 3: The proposition tried by the canons of taxation)
The Most Rev. Dr Thomas Nulty, Roman Catholic Bishop of Meath (Ireland): Back to the Land (1881) Both
capitalists and operatives, therefore, are intensely
disappointed and supremely dissatisfied with these disheartening
results, and mutually reproach each other with fraud and foul dealing
in the division of their common earnings. Their mutual
misunderstandings and rival claims to a larger share than they
actually receive have given rise to "lockouts" on the one side and
"strikes" on the other; to combinations of capitalists among the
employers and "Trade Unions" among the labourers. Thus their mutual
relations, which ought to be of the friendliest character, have at
last settled down into the permanent form of an insane internecine
war, which inflicts irreparable injury on the common interests of
both.
It never occurs to either side that a third party could possibly be liable to blame. I think I have shown that neither party has received, or at all events can retain for his own use and enjoyment, its fair share of their common earnings. The existing system of Land Tenure, like a great national thief, robs both parties of an enormous amount of their earnings for the benefit of a class who do not labour at all. As the operatives complain the
louder, so the case they make
against the capitalists seem really the weaker and the worse founded
of the two. Mr. Cairnes, with many others, proved to evidence that
unless in rare and exceptional cases it is perfectly impossible for
the capitalist to withhold from the operatives their fair share in
their common earnings. Read the whole letter There is in capital no power to
oppress labour;
capital is not the employer of labour; labour is the employer of
capital. (Applause.) That is the natural order; labour came before
capital could be; it is labour produces capital; there is no particle
of capital that can properly be styled capital that labour has not
been exerted to produce. (Hear, hear.) Give labour land; let it get
it on equal terms; secure to the labourer the reward of his
exertions, and the distinction between the labourer and the
capitalist will pass away. With the increase in the wages of labour
if there be great organizations of capital they must necessarily be
co-operative organizations in which labour shall have its full share
and its full right. (Applause.) ... Read the entire article
"A. J. O." (probably Mark Twain) Slavery ... I am capital and I
employ people!
But I gain in other ways besides pecuniary benefit. I have lost the stigma of being a slave driver, and have, acquired instead the character of a man of energy and enterprise, of justice and benevolence. I am a "large employer of labour," to whom the whole country, and the labourer especially, is greatly indebted, and people say, "See the power of capital! These poor labourers, having no capital, could not use the land if they had it, so this great and far-seeing man wisely refuses to let them have it, and keeps it all for himself, but by providing them with employment his capital saves them from pauperism, and enables him to build up the wealth of the country, and his own fortune together." Whereas it is not my capital that does any of these things. It is not my capital but the labourer’s toil that builds up my fortune and the wealth of the country. It is not my employment that keeps him from pauperism, but my monopoly of the land forcing him into my employment that keeps him on the brink of it. It is not want of capital that keeps the labourer from using the land, but my refusing him the use of the land that prevents him from acquiring capital. All the capital he wants to begin with is an axe and a spade, which a week’s earnings would buy him, and for his maintenance during the first year, and at any subsequent time, he could work for me or for others, turnabout, with his work on his own land. Henceforth with every year his capital would grow of itself, and his independence with it, and that this is no fancy sketch, anyone can see for himself by taking a trip into the country, where he will find well-to-do farmers who began with nothing but a spade and an axe (so to speak) and worked their way up in the manner described. ... Read the whole piece |
|
to
email this page to a friend: right click, choose "send"
|
||||||
Wealth
and Want
|
www.wealthandwant.com
|
|||||
... because democracy
alone hasn't yet led to a society in which all can
prosper
|