Forget all those esoteric formulae and supply & demand curves! Here
I’ve adapted an old tale to explain the world of 15 economic theories
and
practices in
more earthy terms. Make sure you get to the final two, which starkly contrast
neoclassical
and geoclassical economics.
WELL-MEANING (BUT IGNORANT) REFORMER
You have two cows.
Your neighbour has none.
You feel guilty for being successful. So instead of giving your
neighbour one of your cows, you write to your local M.P. demanding that
he pass legislation for more government programs to help your neighbour
get a cow.
You arrange for Midnight Oil to do a gig for the cowless, who couldn't
attend because ticket prices are so expensive that only people with 3
or 4 cows can afford to attend. You wear an angry badge that signifies
that you care about cowless people.
CONSERVATIVE
You have two cows.
Your neighbour has none.
So?
COMMUNIST
You have two cows.
The government claims ownership of the cows, giving you no incentive to
work efficiently. You are supposed to be issued milk coupons, no matter
how much is produced. The coupons rarely actually reach those who are
not party of the party elite. You finally get a coupon and wait in line
for hours to get a litre of milk, but by then it’s turned to
yoghurt.
CAPITALISM (according to the obscuring
MYTH)
You have two cows.
You sell one, buy a bull, and build a herd of cows.
CAPITALISM (closer to the REAL story)
You have two cows.
You sell one, buy a bull, and build a herd of cows. You put your cows
on your previously-acquired piece of choice real estate and take a tax
write-off for agricultural land. You sell some of your land (the rest
you keep for speculation) to middle class working people who are now
mortgaged for life and you put your profits into offshore accounts,
further avoiding taxes.
You lobby for a bigger military budget and a national policy of
ignoring the U.N. so that you and other bullish elites can grab other
people’s land and natural resources all over the planet.
CAPITALISM, SCANDINAVIAN STYLE
You have two cows.
The government taxes you to the point where you have to sell both to
support foreign aid in the form of developmental infrastructure, which
means the Third World landowning elite can consequently charge the
landless peasants more rent.
CAPITALISM WITH AGRICULTURAL SUBSIDIES
You have two cows.
Taxpayers are bled so that you can be paid huge sums to underproduce,
which induces others to get in on the subsidy racket. So, while the
desperate Third World is locked out of our markets, the government pays
you for the milk and then pours half of it down the drain.
SLASH & BURN CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You issue a dodgy prospectus to attract a group of shareholders to buy
into the public company which owns the cows. You sell the cows for
peanuts to one of your own private companies, then lease them back to
the public company at exorbitant rates. The public company must then
force the two cows to produce the milk of four cows.
You are surprised when one cow drops dead. You spin an announcement to
financial analysts stating you have downsized and are reducing expenses.
FRENCH CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You go on strike because you want three cows and more subsidies. You go
to lunch and drink wine. Life is good.
RUSSIAN CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You have some vodka. You count the cows again and learn you now have
four cows. The mafia shows up and take all four.
SAUDI CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You don't milk them because you cannot touch any creature's private
parts.
AL QAIDA CORPORATION
You have two cows.
You go into hiding with your cows. Al Jazeera is sent audio tapes of
their mooing. Then you kill them and claim a U.S. bomb blew them up
while they were in hospital.
SENSITIVE NEW AGE COOPERATIVE
You have a cow and a bull.
The bull is depressed. It has spent its life living a lie. It goes away
for two weeks and comes back after a sex-change operation.
You now have two cows - one makes milk, the other doesn't. You try to
sell the transgender cow, but its lawyer sues you for discrimination.
You lose in court. You sell the milk-generating cow to pay the damages.
You now have one rich, transgender, non-milk-producing cow. You change
your business to beef. Animal Liberation pickets your farm.
NEOCLASSICAL LAND-MONOPOLY CAPITALIST
You have two cows and several hectares of land.
Your neighbour is a single mother, has no cows, no land and works a part-time job.
You tell her that if she works longer and harder she could buy one of your cows and become an enterprising capitalist. So she takes on full-time work so that, after 3 months, she has saved enough money to buy one of your cows.
But what use is a cow (or anything, for that matter) without a plot of your land, which is now worth $20,000?
So your neighbour takes on a night shift in addition to her day job, leaving for work after the kids are in bed and arriving home just in time to get them dressed for school.
After a year she has saved enough money to buy that land.
Expressing great regret you explain that, in the meantime, the taxes on her income have paid for the infrastructure that have boosted the value of your land, so that the current market price for that plot is now worth $30,000. Back to the grindstone, baby!
Another year of sweat and toil follows, after which she returns with
the money. But, with hand on heart, you break the news that economic
circumstances have recently driven most single and married mothers to
bring in an extra income in order to save for the ever-escalating price
of land. As no-one’s making any more land, the greater number of
bidders has pushed up the price of the fixed amount of land (this is
called a “healthy, buoyant property market”). It’s now worth $40,000
but it would be a lot easier if she just got a bank loan, you tell her.
However, all those eager bidders for land have also bid up the rate of
interest they’re prepared to suffer, so that interest rates are now
prohibitive. Your neighbour collapses in tears at your feet, but what
can you do? – you didn’t invent the system! Just as our poor mum
relents and considers taking out a mortgage, she finally gets some good
news – in a surprise move, the Reserve Bank has decided to make it
easier on prospective home-owners by reducing interest rates. However,
this has had the effect of making the owning of property more
attractive, so – immediately the interest rate decision is announced –
landowners raise the selling price of land. The “fair market price” of
that plot is now $50,000.
However, under political pressure because of the unaffordability of
property, the federal government announce that it will institute a
First Home Owners’ grant of $7,000. Suddenly that plot is selling for
$57,000.
GEOIST
You have two cows and several acres of land.
Your neighbour is a single mother, has no cows, no land and works a minimum wage job.
You’ve had an amazing vision wherein you see the geoist paradigm in
all its glory and realise that all other reforms are just band-aids, so you
become an activist with ProsperAustralia. You share your insight with your
neighbour and so everyone pulls together to successfully reform our insane
tax laws and system of
land tenure. As a result:
(1) your neighbour can keep all of her hard-earned income, and
(2) those who have enclosed substantial amounts of the Common Wealth
for their own private domain now pay fair land value taxation (LVT) to
society.
Your LVT bill arrives and you realise you have been holding more land
than you really need, so auction off the title to your land and the
improvements on it. Because of genuine tax relief, your neighbour can
now afford to buy the property.
And so - with LVT and trust and angel dust - they all live happily ever
after.